Bremainers Ask….. Mark English

Bremainers Ask….. Mark English

 Mark English is Policy and Media Advisor to European Movement UK and an expert on how the EU functions. Mark was a university teacher, business journalist, and UK civil servant before joining the European Commission, where he worked for almost 25 years, first on education programmes and later on single market policy and economic reform. He then became a spokesperson in the President’s team and for the Irish Commissioner. He was Head of Media for the EC’s London office for six years before a secondment to the European Parliament as a communications manager dealing with tackling disinformation. After serving as adviser to the EC’s director for communication, he joined EMUK part-time in 2022.

Sarah Calvert : How has the EM changed its messaging strategy over the year, and how do you think it will evolve in the future?

Our core message has, since Brexit, been consistent: the UK’s place is in the EU. But emphasis has evolved. Under Conservative governments we focused on the disaster of Brexit and – pending reversing it – demanding achievable things. For example, we opposed the disastrous original draft of the Retained EU Law Bill and advocated for the UK to associate to the Horizon Europe programme.

Under Keir Starmer, we used every available hook to push for ditching the (in)famous ‘red lines’ before the next election – we will never know whether Starmer would have done that if he had remained in power…but sticking rigidly to them contributed to his downfall.

Andy Burnham has made clear applying to join the EU is an option for the next parliament. So we have pivoted to focus on arguing positively for that choice, dovetailing with our comprehensive rebrand.

We now have to convince voters that their own and the UK’s future will be better inside the EU and that there is a viable path to that. We should be ambitious, realistic and honest about the trade-offs and challenges. That is what our Heart of Europe 2036 target is about.

Michael Soffe : Do you think the UK system is “ready” or even “able” to combat “disinformation” leading up to the next General Election?
There is no perfect solution. Neither should we despair. That is what Russia and other perpetrators of Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) want! 

Evidence suggests multiple attempts to interfere in democratic elections. However, UK and other intelligence services say there is little evidence of those attempts succeeding. A massive interference operation recently failed to bring about the election result Russia wanted in neighbouring Moldova. Others can learn from how Moldova defended its democracy..

One of the keys is effectively regulating tech platforms – the EU’s Digital Services Act and the UK’s Online Safety Act and linked regulations share similar virtues and flaws. The EU has been more robust on using competition law to limit tech power. The jury is out on whether its ‘Democracy Shield’ will be effective. Member states have resisted attempts to give the EU wide powers in this field.

Another key is educating the public – the EU and the UK need to do more on this.

A third key is responding based on science. That sometimes means using rebuttals and ‘mythbusters’, notably where ‘disinformation’ is ‘validated’ by mainstream media. In other circumstances, those tactics help spread falsehoods rather than combat them. A strategy that is always right is positive and effective messaging on the issues that bad actors misrepresent.

Mike Cashman : We have a clear message from Terry Reintke about the EU’s readiness to see the UK rejoin. In Mark’s view, from the EU side, what factors would accelerate the UK’s return to the EU, and what would slow it down?

I’ll pick three factors for each scenario:

Accelerate

1/ A positive approach from the UK government, accepting the conditions Michel Barnier recently referred to and ‘selling’ membership to UK voters;

2/ A clear, large, resilient and stable majority in the UK wanting to join;

3/ A dramatic turn in world affairs, such as a Russian incursion into the Baltics, or Trump launching further foreign adventures with catastrophic economic effects (we should not wish for 3/ !)

Slow down

A/ The ‘Farage factor’: fear that a future Reform or Conservative government would reverse the process;

B/ A far-right government in France or (less likely) Germany. A far-right government might block UK accession. It could also cause a crisis that would leave the EU no ‘bandwidth’ for negotiating with the UK. And it could turn UK voters against joining;

C/ Political complications in the EU or the UK. For example, an internal EU conflict over budgetary or rule of law issues. Or an inconclusive UK election result, long negotiations over forming a government or splits in the cabinet.

Finally, the European Parliament has limited power to affect accession issues. The key actors are the Commission and the member states. Any single one can block the process at any stage.

 

Ruth Woodhouse : In the current climate of hate, hostility and radical anti-migrant rhetoric, what gives you hope?

I think the ever-wider recognition in the UK that leaving the EU was a mistake, the willingness of the Burnham government to reopen the issue and to instigate a ‘national conversation’ and the broad welcome from the EU side are all reasons for hope. Along with what I hope is only the beginning of Farage’s and Reform’s well-deserved slide into disrepute and irrelevance.

David Eldridge : Having seen the European Commission and the European Parliament from the inside, what reforms would you like to see in the EU institutions?

During my 26 years as an EU official, I saw a lot of reform in the administration, most of it for the better. But it is rarely quick. The EU has no alternative but to take decisions by consensus, which takes time. 

I think when I first joined the Commission, there was not enough control from the centre – the President’s office and the Secretariat-general. Now there may be too much – individual Commissioners and their staff can feel disempowered. 

Personally, I think there is little point in discussing far-reaching ‘federalist’ reforms, because they will not happen. They would require treaty change and referendums – with uncertain results – in many Member States. Partly but not only, for that reason, several member states are implacably opposed. And it only takes one to block the whole process. 

There might be more mileage (kilometrage?), with more countries set to join the EU, in moving towards what its proposers call a multi-speed Europe, with different levels of integration for different members. Much of that could be done through accession treaties, the ‘enhanced cooperation’ already in EU treaties and through building opt-outs into future EU laws, rather than wholesale treaty change.

Sue Wilson : The pro-EU mood music at the Labour conference seems to have moved. Can we begin to believe that rejoining will be in the Labour and other parties’ manifestos come the next election?

I think there is a good chance of that. The Prime Minister has said so and other pro-European parties cannot afford to trail in Labour’s wake, so are likely to become even more pro-join. But it is not a foregone conclusion – a lot will depend on effective campaigning, by EMUK and others, that helps convince not only voters but also the Westminster ‘bubble’ and key stakeholders, notably the business community.  That is what our Heart of Europe 2036 target is all about.

Steven Wilson : What sort of commitment/action would it take from the UK government for the EU to take us seriously again after all the problems we have caused?

You are right that there is a continuing hangover of distrust. Relations with the UK are also far from the top of the EU’s ‘to do’ list. On the other hand, the UK coming back asking to join would be a significant political win for the EU side.

I do not think the Commission or any member state would block opening  negotiations with the UK. But it is the EU that determines how fast those negotiations proceed. It ‘holds all the cards’ vis-à-vis any applicant country. 

The UK will need to understand that. It will need to demonstrate serious commitment to rapidly (re)aligning UK legislation with EU law and to overcoming domestic political challenges. It will need to refrain from exceptionalist demands (NB – we will NOT in practice need to join the euro and the EU might not even want us to). 

The UK should also make a positive case – though not in the form of arrogant-sounding public proclamations – on how having the UK back will benefit the EU, economically, in the security and defence field, and perhaps in better equipping it to defend democracy and European values.

Lisa Burton : Just how much of a threat to the EU are the AFD in Germany, or Le Pen’s Rassemblement National in France?  Is it overhyped, or could it truly damage how the EU functions? 

I do not think the threat overhyped. 

Le Pen has retreated from Frexit, now French voters have seen Brexit! But her programme is incompatible with EU membership. She promises a referendum to amend the French constitution in ways conflicting with the EU Treaties. She proposes unilaterally to cut France’s EU budget contribution in half – putting France at daggers drawn with the Commission and other member states. Le Pen’s economic programme – like that of her far-left rival Jean-Luc Melenchon – could create a ‘Liz Truss effect’ at the heart of the eurozone. An EU-wide economic crisis could follow.

I cannot see Le Pen following Giorgia Meloni’s conciliatory path. However, I think the damage to the French economy could be so immense that she would in the end have to back down. The EU should survive a Le Pen presidency. 

The AfD is a long way from being a federal governing party, as others will not share power with it. Parts of it are so extremist – one activist recently called for Germany to retake Alsace-Lorraine – that even Le Pen will not work with it. The unlikely event of the AfD gaining power would be existential for the EU.

Bremainers Ask ……. Lisa Burton

Bremainers Ask ……. Lisa Burton

Originally from the Rhondda Valleys, South Wales, Lisa lives in the Canary Islands. She is the owner/director of a distribution company that operates in the UK and EU. She has been Bremain In Spain’s vice chair since 2020 and is now our newly elected Chair. She is also a member of the national council of European Movement UK and chair of its Conduct Committee.

Ruth Woodhouse : Do you feel that European Movement UK is sufficiently high-profile, and how could it be more so?

As the oldest UK pro-EU group, founded in 1949 with Winston Churchill as a founding member, EMUK wasn’t particularly well known outside political circles. That has changed significantly. Membership has grown from around 5,000 in 2020 to 26,000 today, with 100+ local groups, hundreds of activists, and a vast 300k supporter base. Nevertheless, becoming a household name remains a challenge.

Raising EMUK’s profile has been a priority, and we are getting there. You now regularly see and hear EMUK figures quoted across the media, on Radio 2, LBC and even GB News, with a particularly good relationship with The Independent.

Is that where we want to be? No. Are we on the right track? Yes. But in a media landscape that thrives on division, a calm, sensible voice can sometimes be the hardest to project.

 

Michael Soffe : How has Brexit affected running a UK-based business from Spain?

Oh yes! For 20+ years my business has distributed home entertainment media as a retailer and wholesaler: vinyl, CDs, Blu-ray/DVDs, Box Sets, movie merch, computer games and so on.

Before Brexit, Amazon ran a pan-European programme that let us distribute stock across Amazon’s EU warehouses based on demand. Around 20% of our sales went through this system, and we have never recovered around 80% of that business.

We were familiar with customs paperwork because we sell business-to-business globally, but Brexit made trading with the EU much more complicated. We now have to provide country-of-origin information for around 400,000 products and navigate much more bureaucracy.  Even though we export daily, things still go wrong sometimes. It takes more time, more staff hours, and more money. It’s harder, slower and more complicated.

 

Helen Johnston : Do you think the stereotypes promoted in the British press regarding British people living in Spain and other European countries are problematic for our campaigning, and what can we do to counter them?

Yes, 100%. And I also think that British migrants in Spain are more stereotyped than those in France or Belgium, say. The perception that huge swathes of us voted for Brexit is a prime example: as is the argument that we are not a burden, never claim benefits, etc., but somehow migrants to the UK are. It’s all nonsense, of course. It’s hard to change this; people in the UK aren’t really interested in us, and newspapers only want clickbait, but I think one of the best approaches is to highlight individual stories and explain the issues British migrants face, while calling out disinformation when we see it. Emotions work better than facts.

Sue Wilson : What do you think Bremain does best and what do you think we could improve on?

Bremain punches well above its weight and is well known among politicians, activists, and the media, and has strong relationships with organisations such as the Embassy. This stems from the early campaigning, and your high-profile court case, our work with other pro-EU organisations, and features such as Bremainers Ask. Above all, it’s our committed members who continue to contribute to the conversation, campaign, lobby, and keep the goal of rejoining the EU alive.

I do think we could better highlight our unique position as a community of British citizens living in Spain and experiencing the consequences of Brexit first-hand. Sharing more members’ stories and issues would make what we do more personal, relevant and distinctive, while also giving us stronger material for media and social media. Doing this effectively and efficiently with the time available is the problem.

 

Steve Burnham : Do you think EU membership erodes the sovereignty of member states?

Simply put, no, and this is something the Brexiters never quite understood. No country is truly sovereign, because that would require complete isolation or total autonomy, which is almost impossible in today’s interconnected global world and economic co-dependency.  Every time a nation signs a trade deal and agrees to rules, joins an international organisation, signs up to international laws, joins a coalition like NATO, etc., it gives up some sovereignty, because it abides by rules it did not solely make. Modern-day sovereignty is more about a nation’s ability to maintain domestic control and economic strength while resisting foreign coercion.

 

Karen Tuck : Do you feel that an MP for us Brits living overseas would be helpful in letting Westminster understand the issues we face; after all, we are currently unrepresented as British Citizens in Europe and the UK?

Yes, 100%. Our MP’s do not understand the issues we face, particularly post-Brexit. You may be aware that Bremain is part of a coalition effort by New Europeans and Unlock Democracy calling for overseas constituencies. We have provided evidence to select committees on this, and I have studied other nations’ systems. What is clear is that the UK government is not very good at franchising its overseas nationals. The French are excellent at doing so and allow several voting methods for their overseas citizens. It’s the system I’d like to see replicated for UK nationals abroad.

Next Month

Mark English is Policy and Media Advisor to European Movement UK and an expert on how the EU functions. Mark was a university teacher, business journalist, and UK civil servant before joining the European Commission, where he worked for almost 25 years, first on education programmes and later on single market policy and economic reform. He then became a spokesperson in the President’s team and for the Irish Commissioner. He was Head of Media for the EC’s London office for six years before a secondment to the European Parliament as a communications manager dealing with tackling disinformation. After serving as adviser to the EC’s director for communication, he joined EMUK part-time in 2022.

Please email your questions to us no later than Saturday 10 October.

 

Bremainers Ask……  Alyn Smith

Bremainers Ask…… Alyn Smith

Alyn Smith – Scottish National Party MSP

As well as being the MSP for Stirling, Alyn serves as Convener of the Criminal Justice Committee and Deputy Convenor of the CPG on Tourism. Prior to being elected to the Scottish Parliament, Alyn served as the MP for Stirling for 5 years and as an MEP in Brussels for 16 years, where he represented Scotland.

Alyn continues to be a strong advocate for independence in Europe and serves as the Vice President of European Movement Scotland.

Michael Soffe : If you had one piece of advice for those of us who wish to “Rejoin”, what would it be?

Don’t fight old battles and don’t expect any favours. We’re not special – the EU’s first priority will, quite rightly, always be the members inside the club, not others outside (however near or far). Even in the last few weeks, we have seen a supposedly serious UK think-tank come up with a lamentable blueprint that was full of “cakeism” nonsense but did not have any reference to the overriding fact that the EU has its own interests too.

 

Ruth Woodhouse : To what extent is the Scottish parliament able to engage with the UK parliament regarding Brexit and future relationships with the EU?

Pretty limited. There is the Partnership Assembly, which some folks are very excited to be part of, but in my experience it is ineffectual and disengaged even from a Westminster perspective. We’ll take what opportunities we can to engage and be vocal. I’m hoping to be the Convener of the EU Cross Party Group in Holyrood and welcome all engagement, but the primary talks are government-government and pretty patchy.

 

Andrew Hesselden : How can we influence the Scottish and UK governments to see the value in mutual Freedom of Movement of People (in Europe) once again?

We don’t need to convince the Scottish government. I hope the fact the former PM talked of “an island of strangers” keeps him awake at night. There might be more of an opportunity going forward but I have my doubts. My suggestion would be that the campaign stresses that which has been lost can be got back and focuses on those advantages we win with EU membership. Sadly, I’m not sure many people articulate it beyond passport queues.

 

Lisa Burton : Many young people have grown up knowing only post-Brexit Britain. How do we make the case for Europe to a generation that never experienced freedom of movement?

This is one of my biggest worries. You don’t miss what you’ve never had. Same as when tuition fees were introduced in England, it became the new normal within a couple of years so quickly due to student turnover. The Irish European Movement have a lot of good materials on EU advantages which could be repurposed, but there remains a pressing need to make folks aware that there are huge life-changing advantages with EU membership they’re not getting.

Alyn Smith, SNP MEP

Matt Burton : Having served in the European Parliament, Westminster and Scotland, what differences in political culture struck you the most? What could each learn from the others?

My biggest point would be to scrap First-Past-the-Post as soon as possible. If you are an ambitious politician and want to get things done, knowing that you will at some point need the votes of your opponents for things you care about gives an entirely different context to discussion and personal interactions across parties. In Brussels and Holyrood no vote will be won without a majority; as nobody has a majority, it will always need to be a compromise. The idea that FPTP delivers firm government is a fiction; it delivers politicians who think in terms of goodies and baddies.

 

David Eldridge : In two speeches as a departing MEP you famously asked the EU to “leave a light on” and to not let Scotland down. How are they doing on those fronts?

There’s no doubt in my mind that if, as, and when Scotland votes for independence, we will have allies aplenty who are keen to help us through the process. Equally, I don’t expect the EU to do us any favours or do our job for us. We presented a proposal for the Northern Ireland regulations to cover Scotland also but given this did not have UK support where there was sympathy for us, the EU was not going to step into the constitutional order of a third country. Where NI was different was that it had several international agreements with an EU member state.

 

Steven Wilson : How do you square the circle between the arguments for being part of a union (EU) and the arguments for leaving a union (UK)?

Because much as they use the same words they are self-evidently not the same thing. My local bowling club has a President – she doesn’t get to live in the White House or illegally bomb Iran. The EU and UK are political constructs with different histories and to my mind the UK has served its time. Scotland can build a new state on ancient foundations but fit for the next decades.

 

Susan Scarrott : Is there still a strong desire by Scottish voters to rejoin the EU?

Yes, not unanimous obviously but we’re at settled will levels of support, 73% at the last opinion poll and that is without much of a campaign. This would also be far higher but for the Scottish politicians of UK parties not being able to articulate their views because their head office says no.

Next month

With Sue Wilson retiring next month, and assuming the proposal is ratified at our AGM, Lisa Burton will be taking over as Chair of Bremain in Spain. So, what would you like to ask the new chair? Please email your questions to us no later than Tuesday 8 September.

Bremainers Ask….  10th anniversary special

Bremainers Ask…. 10th anniversary special

To commemorate the anniversary of the Brexit referendum, we asked six former contributors to give us their thoughts on Brexit 10 years on. Here’s what they had to say.

David Henig

Behind the daily dramas, the story of Brexit was that reality won over fantasy, that geography and inter-connectivity matter, and that the UK-EU negotiation is therefore permanent. These talks could come as members, angry divorcees, or a former couple returning to civility, but there are too many subjects of common interest for the relationship to be ignored as some would like.

Nor will the UK ever be dictating the terms, though it remains an important neighbour to Member States, but equally the EU won’t be able to ignore the relationship either. Once this all becomes clear, it is simply (!) a matter of the UK understanding what it wants and setting up everything required to achieve this, as against an EU for which such things are routine for good and bad. I fear though that such basics will continue to be ignored.

 

Gina Miller

Brexit was built on lies. The way back must be built on honesty.

Brexit was won on lies, by people with little interest in those left to live with the consequences. Ten years on, ordinary citizens are still paying, not least expats in Europe, who lost freedom of movement to a slogan.

The toll is stark: billions in lost exports, weaker growth, deferred investment. But the damage was also democratic, leaving a corrosive mistrust that populism thrives on.

Many of you want to rejoin, and I share that destination. But rejoining could take 10 to 15 years, while the poison festers. There is a faster way to heal. A Swiss option, the EU–Switzerland “Bilaterals III” deal of March 2026 is less elegant than membership but achievable in a few years and is not about surrender but serious, sensible action. By restoring cooperation, lifting barriers, and putting free movement back on the table, any future rejoin would come from far more stable, stronger ground.

The window is open – a Reform-led government could shut it within three years.

 

Anand Menon

Ten years on from the EU referendum and Brexit is still not ‘done’. Partly, that’s a function of how awful the EU is at joining with neighbours who do not aspire to join. Partly – ask the Swiss – it’s down to the fact that maintaining close ties requires almost permanent adaptation.

What is beyond doubt is that being outside the EU will mean we spend more time thinking about it than we ever did as a member state. The fact is – as neighbours of China and the US will confirm – living on the doorstep of a continental sized economy is never comfortable or easy. This is not necessarily a case for rejoining. Simply a warning that being out will bring its own challenges. 

Liz Webster

Ten years on, Brexit stands as one of the greatest acts of economic self-harm in modern British history.

As a farmer, I have watched British agriculture become the sacrificial lamb of Brexit. Brexit has opened our market to greater competition, while our European neighbours continue to benefit from collective support and strategic protection.

At a time of global instability, from climate shocks to conflicts threatening vital trade routes such as the Strait of Hormuz, Europe has recognised food as a strategic asset. European farmers are receiving additional support to maintain production and resilience. Meanwhile, British farmers face falling confidence, soaring costs and successive governments that refuse to put food security at the heart of national policy.

Brexit promises have all turned to dust, sovereignty has materialised as weakened resilience. More British voters now realise that in an increasingly uncertain world, strength comes from cooperation, not isolation, and want to rejoin the EU.

 

Richard Corbett

Contrary to what many politicians expected, the public didn’t rally behind Brexit once it had happened. A majority now say they support rejoining the EU. Leave voters see that Brexit bears no resemblance to what was promised.

Brexit has damaged the economy to an even greater extent than predicted, lost an annual £100bn of tax revenue, created extra red tape and inconvenience for UK citizens trading with or travelling to our neighbouring countries, and made it more difficult for Britain to participate in the wide range of matters handled multilaterally within the EU. This includes medical research, access to police databases, identifying and handling dangerous chemicals, food safety, trade sanctions, student exchanges, recognition of qualifications, and much else.

Furthermore, the geopolitical situation has changed, with a militarily aggressive Russia, an unreliable USA, and a more assertive China, making us increasingly aware of the interests and values we share across Europe. Time for more ambition!

 

Caroline Lucas

Looking back at the referendum 10 years ago, what can we learn? That top-down, technocratic arguments in favour of Remain didn’t work then (as some of us warned that they wouldn’t at the time) and certainly won’t work in the campaign to rejoin. Instead, we need to make a forward-looking, inclusive, values-based argument, based not only on the fact that it’s clearly in our best economic interests, but also on the idea of choosing a side. In an increasingly insecure world, with the US an ever more insular and unreliable partner, our future lies with our European neighbours, who still largely share our democratic values.

It’s time for the Government to tear up its red lines and start taking practical steps towards EU membership. The world has changed and so has public opinion. What better way for a new Prime Minister to signal a new beginning?

Coming next

Bremainers Ask will be taking a break in July, but we’re delighted to announce our contributor for August Alyn Smith – Scottish National Party MSP.

As well as being the MSP for Stirling, Alyn serves as Convener of the Criminal Justice Committee, focusing on Europe, the economy and growth, public service reform and building a case for independence in Europe.

Alyn served as an MEP in Brussels for 15 years representing Scotland and is Vice President of European Movement Scotland.

If you wish to submit a question(s) for consideration, please email us no later than noon on Saturday 8 August.

 

 

Bremainers Ask ……. Andrew Hesselden

Bremainers Ask ……. Andrew Hesselden

Andrew is a strategic communications specialist and campaigner focused on UK–EU mobility and citizens’ rights.
Having founded the “Save Freedom of Movement” campaign, Andrew also raises awareness of “90-in-180-day” issues with his “180 Days in Spain” initiative.
Andrew serves on the National Council of European Movement UK and is working to build a Coalition for Mobility in Europe.

Matt Burton: “Do you think UK politicians now better understand the real-life consequences of losing freedom of movement?”

Yes — understanding is improving.  We see this in the responses from MPs when our members write letters and we’ve had positive meetings too.

For years, Freedom of Movement of People was discussed in the UK as a mostly negative thing and only connected with immigration to the UK; never about Brits moving elsewhere or travelling easily without complex border control processes.

Increasingly, politicians are now hearing directly from families, students, businesses, musicians and part-year residents affected by the loss of FOM.  The stories are making a difference.

Before Brexit, I don’t think people spent their time thinking about treaty structures or EU Directives on Freedom of Movement. They simply lived their lives across Europe and travelled in a way that felt ordinary.

That is why the change has been so upsetting and disruptive for many people.

 

John Gaskell: “Is there anything that can be done for families with split residency, e.g. families consisting of a UK citizen and an EU one, with homes in both countries that are being forced to spend at least some of their time apart?”

This is one of the least discussed but most painful consequences of Brexit.

Many families built perfectly lawful cross-border lives under Freedom of Movement without ever imagining those arrangements could suddenly become difficult or impossible. They did everything the law asked of them.

And in many cases, people were not even affected until quite late in the Brexit process. Parents retired abroad. Children moved overseas and started families. People suddenly found themselves becoming grandparents living across borders when they didn’t expect to.

After almost 30 years of the Single Market, living and building families across borders had simply become normal for millions of people. And when “normal” suddenly changes that is hugely disruptive.

People who once lived across borders with ease have increasingly found themselves being pushed to decide where they belong — as though belonging in multiple places is somehow no longer acceptable.

In reality, that idea of being “at home anywhere” was exactly what the EU and Single Market were about.

So, I do think both the Withdrawal Agreement and the Trade & Cooperation Agreement have been woefully inadequate and would like to see both revisited or added to, especially if nothing bigger or better is going to happen for a while.

 

Philip Burton: “Why is the government reluctant to negotiate a visa waiver with individual EU countries or, if it is possible, with the EU to expand our 90 in 180 period?”

I think UK governments have been reluctant partly because recognising the issue would mean acknowledging that liberal mobility arrangements are genuinely useful.  That would have been at odds with their Brexit choices.

Before Brexit, millions of people built lives around the ability to move freely and flexibly across Europe. And once you begin recognising the practical value that liberal mobility and the Single Market brought to ordinary people’s lives, it raises wider questions about why the UK left those arrangements.

That is why I think talking about mobility is key to unlocking much of the wider Brexit impasse.

We still find ourselves wanting and needing to live/work/study in, sell to and buy from our closest neighbours.  As UK politicians begin to recognise the value of closer mobility arrangements again, I think their red lines will continue to fade away.

For a long time, the UK Foreign Office told us that it was not UK government policy to negotiate visa waivers for UK citizens.  But I haven’t seen that response for a while so maybe that policy has changed.

The bilateral visa-waivers for certain third countries such as New Zealand and Canada, are historic and most pre-date the Schengen Treaty, so it’s unclear how useful they are as a model for what’s possible now.  However, I think they are still noteworthy because they demonstrate that the 90-in-180 day problem was recognised as early as 1995 when there were only 7 Schengen countries.  Now there are 29.  They also demonstrate that different arrangements are fully compatible with the standard Schengen border processes as they are today.

 

Michael Sims: “Is there likely to be a change to the 90 in 180 days restriction in the future, with perhaps Spain recognising those who have owned properties for years before Brexit and our human rights to use our property when we like?”

It’s impossible to know.

I do believe change will happen. Although whether this specific issue is resolved directly or simply overtaken by bigger changes in UK–EU relations, remains to be seen.

When Brexit happened, if all the full-year residents in the UK or EU27 had been told on Brexit day to leave their homes, apply for visas and wait for permission to return, there would have been Europe-wide outrage. But that is effectively what happened to many part-year dwellers — and their situation was treated as politically invisible.

In Spain, the problem is compounded further by the lack of a suitable visa that lets someone spend far less than 182 days in Spain but more than 90 days in the Schengen area combined.  You might have work that takes you regularly to Germany for 40 days, a family visit to France for 30 days and a holiday in Italy or Greece for 15 days and be unable to enter Spain for more than a few days.

Our campaign is about the people, not the property: it’s not about the assets you owned but is about the decisions you made while an EU citizen.

We also hope the work will benefit a wider community of people too, including all travellers after Brexit – in both directions. I hope the government eventually expands its thinking around youth mobility because young people will want and expect mobility that lasts well beyond the age of 30.

 

Steven Wilson: “How do you square the circle between a campaign seeking for Brits to spend 6 months a year in the EU being seen as counter-productive by rejoin campaigns, when others feel the rules should be the same as they are for EU citizens travelling to the UK?”

I do not think our campaign competes with efforts to rebuild closer UK–EU relations.

In many ways, it complements them.  We are demonstrating the lived human impact of losing mobility in a way that people from many different backgrounds and professions can relate to. That is why we focus much more on stories of lived experience than specific solutions.

Keeping people apart for another decade probably won’t do anything to help UK–EU relations.

We agree that rules for British travellers to Spain should ideally be the same as they are for Spanish citizens travelling to the UK.

One of the things we are asking for (if politicians won’t restore mutual Freedom of Movement yet) is for visitor arrangements for UK travellers to Spain to mirror the arrangements Spanish citizens already enjoy in the UK, which is up to 6 months each time they visit.

 

Lisa Burton: “Your work brings together diverse groups – seasonal workers, retirees, freelancers; how do you unify such different interests under one campaign?”

Underneath the differences, the core issue is often very similar.

Whether it is retirees, freelancers, split families, seasonal workers or business owners, all relied in different ways on the ability to move and maintain lives across Europe with relative ease.

Visas (if they even exist) get in the way of that.

That is one reason I am trying to help build a broader coalition for mobility across Europe — bringing together people and sectors who may experience these problems differently, but whose underlying need for mobility is often remarkably similar.

 

David Eldridge: “What are the chances of Labour including the restoration of Freedom of Movement (or even rejoining the EU altogether) in their next manifesto?”

That’s the “million euro question” and it is difficult to predict, but I do think the political conversation is gradually shifting.

The reasons we joined the EEC (now EU) in the first place have not gone away.

Over time, I think pressure for closer cooperation with Europe will continue to grow.

Whether that leads directly to restoring Freedom of Movement or eventually rejoining the EU remains uncertain, but I do not think the current settlement feels stable or sustainable in the long term.  From recent media activity, it looks to me like we are being prepared for some big shifts to happen.

You only have to look at the long queues in some airports to see what a political problem this must be for the government.

 

Anon: “As the public become increasingly aware of the costs and limitations of a Brexit reset, are they becoming increasingly accepting of a full rejoin campaign, rather than the current step-by-step approach?”

I think we are on a path that necessarily winds around the forest.

We have to bring people on the journey with us, and that may involve a few diversions and “going round the houses” to pick up more passengers along the way.

That is why I don’t see the discussions around liberal mobility arrangements, youth mobility or joining the Single Market as distractions or delays. I think they are probably necessary steps on that journey to our politicians realising we just need to rejoin the EU.

The public already knows.  It’s just our politicians that need to catch up.

Next Month

To commemorate the anniversary of the Brexit referendum, six former contributors will be giving us their thoughts on Brexit ten years on. Tune in next month to read what they have to say.

Bremainers Ask ……. Professor Christina Pagel

Bremainers Ask ……. Professor Christina Pagel

Christina is Professor of Operational Research at University College London, using mathematical tools to support the delivery of health services. She is also President Elect of the UK Operational Research Society and a Fellow of the Academy of Medical Sciences.

Since January 2025, she has been tracking authoritarian actions by the Trump administration (trumptractiontracker.info) and writing about their implications for the US and internationally.

Christina is passionate about healthcare and defending liberal democracy and is a regular commentator on social media, with 66k followers on Bluesky.

Valerie Chaplin : Will Trump last out his term or will the US see sense and oust him before he does any more damage?

I’m not sure if he will last, but to me the most likely reason for his exit is ill-health (including death). I can’t see the Republicans ousting him. If the Democrats win both the House and the Senate in the midterms, then they might be able to, if they can get enough Republicans to vote with them in the Senate, but I still think it is very unlikely.

 

David Eldridge : Will Trump’s unpopularity across most of Europe harm the poll ratings of far-right parties either modelling themselves on or openly courting his support (Reform, AfD, Vox, RN etc)?

Yes and no. I think parties that explicitly tie themselves too closely to Trump might be harmed by association and I can’t see them angling for his endorsement for that reason (especially after the US open endorsement for Orban in Hungary ended badly for Orban). That said, I think far-right parties can adopt many of Trump’s strategies and that this can work for them (e.g. leaning into the culture war, painting opponents as out-of-touch elites, stoking hatred for immigrants) and they can do this without even mentioning Trump or the US. Additionally, they can benefit from huge donations of Trump-aligned billionaires/right-wing foundations, again without necessarily tying themselves to Trump. 

 

Susan Scarrott : What do you consider were the greatest losses to your scientific field after leaving the EU and what would be the benefits of rejoining?

The biggest losses were scientists and science funding. On the former, applications for undergraduate and postgraduate study from the EU have dropped off a cliff (much more expensive for them and they need expensive visas). Even more worrying, while previously we used to get many applications for academic jobs (e.g. postdoctoral researcher or tenured positions) from brilliant EU scientists, these have disappeared. I can’t remember the last time an EU citizen applied for a postdoc position I was on the interview panel for. I think this is a tragic loss. We also lost access to exchange programmes with the EU and access to some European funding schemes (e.g. Horizon). Some of these are now restored, which is very welcome, but it has still been several years of lost opportunities.

Steven Wilson : Have Trump’s actions caused permanent damage to US global collaborations and standing, or will international relations return to ‘normal’ once he is removed from power?

Permanent is a long time – after all the UK is no longer enemies with France, Spain or Germany against whom we fought many wars. But as long as a MAGA version of the Republicans is in power, international relations and the US global influence are both severely weakened. If and when Democrats return to power, it will take a long time to build back collaboration to where it was, because the trust is gone that agreements will outlive an administration. I also suspect that this might be the start of the US decline as the pre-eminent global superpower (especially as China continues to rise), so perhaps in that sense the damage is permanent.

 

Lisa Burton : Why do you think evidence-based policy so often struggles to compete with political narratives or misinformation?

Excellent question! I think it’s a number of things. Evidence-based policy tends to be slower and to call for slower, more careful actions – which is out of step with what people want (quick change). Evidence-based policy also tends to involve at least some trade-offs, and people prefer to hear that things can be made better with little cost or effort on their part (I mean who doesn’t?). The growth of AI has made coming up with superficially convincing arguments (and pseudo-science) to support populists’ policies very easy, and social media has provided the means to amplify it. 

Evidence-based policy also requires changing your mind or direction if the evidence changes or better ideas emerge, and politicians are punished for this and so are social media influencers. This creates an incentive structure that rewards doubling down and extreme positions, which counteract evidence-based policy. I personally experienced this during COVID, when my followers would ‘reward’ me for any negative news about Covid or government policy but ‘punish’ (or ignore) when I posted good news or in support of a government policy. It can be very tempting to go towards the ‘reward’ and you have to consciously stop yourself.

 

Anon : With close to 3000 actions on your Trump Action Tracker, are there any particular misdeeds that stand out for you?

I think all of it is pretty bad – the combined attacks on rule of law, the media, and science. But what I personally find most disturbing is the utterly blatant white supremacist propaganda being pumped out on X by the Dept of Homeland Security and the in-your-face racism of Trump against non-white immigrants, especially (at the moment) Venezuelans and Somalis. When combined with all the actions that speak to a fundamental belief that whoever has the biggest army should do what they like, when they like, to whom they like, it feels like a return to very dark times.

 

NEXT MONTH Andrew Hesselden

Andrew is a strategic communications specialist and campaigner focused on UK–EU mobility and citizens’ rights. Having founded the “Save Freedom of Movement” campaign, Andrew also raises awareness of “90-in-180-day” issues with his “180 Days in Spain” initiative. Andrew serves on the National Council of European Movement UK and is working to build a Coalition for Mobility in Europe.

If you wish to put forward a question(s) for Andrew, please email us no later than noon on Saturday 9 May.